By Jeff Bell
Image: dragana991, iStock
We all seem to have grown up with scary dreams and fears of monsters.
Kids’ books and movies precipitated them, reinforced them, or both. Stories by adults and older kids played a part. This was particularly intense in ages 4 to 8—ghosts and monsters.
Thankfully, for most of us by 12, they were not so prevalent.
These were the findings of research by team David Bauer in California 50 years ago and team Peter Muris in the Netherlands 25 years ago.
But Muris found that worry is another matter, and it appears to grow in teenage years. While imaginary creatures are less of a concern, practical matters such as humiliation, test performance and school are front and centre.
Then there is another phase in our 30s, where the main subjects of concern are identity, career and romantic relationships. In our mid-life we are bedeviled by concerns for our health, mobility and isolation.
All of these are grist for our inner voice mill.
It’s a matter explored deeply by father and daughter researchers, Ross and Rachel Menzies in the fascinating Being. Why it’s harder to be human than a hamster or a herring.
Our inner voice is constantly warning us of terrible possibilities and worse. Its claim is to keep us safe. But it distort, it exaggerates, it often lies. But we keep listening to and treating it with respect.
According to team Adrian Wells at University of Manchester, it is all about:
our thoughts about our thoughts—known as metacognition.
They have used a questionnaire to determine subjects’ beliefs about the process of worry, and what we think it achieves.
If we believe that our worry process is a useful thing, the more attentively we will listen to it—and the more prone to emotional pain we will be. This is even more of a problem for clinical patients with anxiety and mood disorders.
Legendary theorist in psychiatry and psychology, Aaron Beck, discovered the role of the inner voice in depressive illness and he developed a system to treat it, on his way to founding the practice of cognitive therapy.
Beck noticed that patients sought encouragement following disapproval, rather than suffering.
He also termed “automatic thoughts” for the negative events and thoughts that gave rise to the emotional shifts of his patients—that it was their conscious thoughts or “inner voice”, distorted and mean-spirited, that created anguish. This became patently clear in face-to-face contact when the patient’s emotional reactions revealed their negative internal chatter.
Beck was able to devise 6 types of distortions and train his clients to identify which of these were in their thinking. There were [and are because this is in common use today] 3 categories—negative ideas about: oneself; the world; and the future.
This then led to the understanding that in the clinical context, the inner voice drives feelings which drive behaviours.
Could this be the case, to a lesser extent, for all of us?
The power of the inner voice is mostly due to risk aversion—so useful when in our evolutionary journey we faced incessant existential threats. For the majority of us, our needs for shelter, safety and nutrition are taken care of, so our risks have been much reduced. Yet our inner voice may keep chattering on.
So, how to deal with it?
Steven Hayes at the University of Nevada devised acceptance and commitment therapy which helps sufferers recognise that they create their own thoughts: which don’t have to be obeyed or acted on, which are not a threat and which may or may not be important. Importantly, there is a choice about how much attention is paid to these worries.
For the leader, not necessarily a therapist, an understanding of the inner voice and its treatment is extremely useful. For the day-to-day we can lead the discussion and develop a coaching approach—asking, not telling—to help raise awareness and action.
For anything deep-seated and ongoing, professional help should be sought. This is comfortably within the scope of an Employee Assistance Program.
And if we ourselves are suffering from unwelcome dominance of inner voice: engagement ranging from a skillful coach to a therapist to a clinical psychologist.